By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
August 22, 2003
This proposed standard for centralizing control of the WLAN could be the solution to all the headaches of ever-growing enterprise networks. Then again, maybe not.
Wi-Fi LANs just keep growing and growing. And, that’s great, unless you have to manage dozens or hundreds of them one by one. Then, maybe it’s not so great. Lightweight Access Point Protocol (LWAPP) an Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) draft standard, may provide a remedy for this management headache.
LWAPP offers an open, vendor-neutral standard to the problem. This proposed standard is primarily the creation of Airespace, a Wi-Fi network infrastructure management company (read: WLAN switch vendor), which owns LWAPP related patents. Airespace is joined by NTT DoCoMo, the Japanese cell phone giant, and Legra Systems, another Wi-Fi switch company, in championing LWAPP.
Sounds great? Well, maybe it will be, maybe it won’t. Not only is LWAPP an open standard at a very early stage of its development, it has some large powerful business enemies. You see, the 800-pound gorilla of networking, Cisco has a lot invested in their own proprietary approach to Wi-Fi management, the Structured Wireless-Aware Network Framework, which powers up Cisco’s CiscoWorks Wireless LAN Solution Engine 2.0.
This style of management is called ‘Fat AP’ or ‘Peer-to-Peer’ architecture and this kind of technology is also supported by Proxim. It works well, but it is expensive and requires access points that can work in a vendor’s particular infrastructure.
Of course, Airespace, in particular (with its LWAPP-related patents) would benefit if LWAPP makes it from IETF draft to standard. What we have is a classic case of a vendor taking their own proprietary policy and trying to make it an open standard. But since other vendors, especially Cisco, already has a lot invested in their proprietary standards, LWAPP faces strong opposition. So, what might appear to some to be a battle between different technology approaches is really a battle between businesses.
The Ideas of LWAPP
- Aruba Switch Gets a Director
- Searching for Wi-Fi Security Solutions
- Deploying WLANs at Marinas
- AirDefense Describes Lack of Client Security at Show
- Switches Improve WLAN Range and Performance
LWAPP is meant to be a network protocol for access points that also provides for centralized management. The idea for LWAPP started with the observation that access points work as access servers with IP addresses. This means that although access points are usually treated as dumb Layer 2 (data link) devices, they could also work as Layer 3 (network level) devices. For more on layers see The 7 Layers of the OSI Model.
LWAPP is meant to be the open, standard protocol for access point management. In turn, this would be used as the foundation for network management programs that could be controlled from a switch or router console.
Once deployed, LWAPP’s first goal will be to reduce the filter and policy processing needed in an access point. That work will be centralized and any changes will be broadcast to the access points. Then, LWAPP designers will also use this same centralized management architecture to deal with traffic management, authentication, encryption, and policy enforcement. Finally, LWAPP will provide a generic encapsulation and transport mechanism so one vendor’s LWAPP console can work with multiple vendor’s LWAPP-enabled access points.
At the same time, as management is centralized, LWAPP-equipped access points would have more memory and processor power so that they could run system access policies or manage traffic without needing to call-in to a centralized server for constant instructions.
Does it work? Airespace is already using LWAPP in their commercial AireWave Director Software. In this application, LWAPP is the underpinning for manual and automatic access point configuration and management. As for the actual network management, existing standards like Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMP) would be used.
Will LWAPP fly? Sure, the technology is being deployed. The real question is will it become a real IETF standard. With the opposition of Cisco, that will not be easy. The draft standard expires in mid-December 2003. By then, we should know one way or the other.
For now, if you want to experiment with it, you need to invest in Airespace software and equipment. For the rest of us, we’ll need to wait and see if LWAPP becomes just another proprietary network management technology or a cure-all for our network management ailments.