Review: Three Linux Wi-Fi Managers

By Eric Geier

October 23, 2008

An overview of three Linux programs that help users manage Wi-Fi connections: Network Manager, Wicd, and KWifiManager.

We went on a mission to find, experiment with, and examine Linux programs to help manage our Wi-Fi connections. We found many different networking utilities. Most are based around profile-based configuration, where connection details such as encryption keys are saved for reccurring connections. Some even support per-network IP and DNS settings. This is great, for example, if your work network requires a static IP address, while at home your router using its DHCP server; IP address information is saved for each network's profile. In addition to a simple signal indicator for wireless networks, some utilities offer details such as signal and noise level graphs and the displaying of the channels used by the wireless networks.

On our search, here are some of the network connectivity utilities we came across: NetworkManager, Wicd, KWiFiManger, WaveSelect, AP Radar, NetChoose, gWireless. We're going to review Network Manager, Wicd, and KWifiManager.

NetworkManager

The first networking utility we'll review is NetworkManager, an interface for both wired and wireless connections, installed by default in Ubuntu. Though NetworkManager lacks advanced functionality, such as per network IP settings and channel info, it includes the basic features.

As Figure 1 shows, a click on the tray icon displays all the detected Wi-Fi networks and shortcuts to perform networking tasks. When you click a wireless network, you're prompted if a encryption key is required and then it connects. A profile is automatically created for the network, including any encryption keys you entered.

Figure 1

Figure 1. Click to view larger.

You can click on Connect to Other Wireless Network to manually enter a network name (SSID) and the security type, in order to connect to non-broadcast or hidden Wi-Fi networks. Additionally, you can create your own ad-hoc or computer-to-computer network by clicking Create New Wireless Network.

As Figure 2 shows, right-clicking the icon lets you disable/enable the wired and wireless connectivity. Clicking Connection Information shows you the details of the current connection, such as the data rate, IP settings, and the hardware (or MAC) address. To view and/or change the profiles created for networks you've connected to, you can click Edit Wireless Networks.... Shown in Figure 3, for each profile, you can change the security/encryption settings and, for networks with multiple access points (APs), you can add the MAC addresses of all the APs that use the same network name (BSSID).

You'll find NetworkManager provides a simple networking experience when working with simple networks. You may want to look elsewhere if you work on multiple networks that each require advanced settings (such as static IP addresses) or need a tool that provides detailed signal strength and channel information.

Pronounced 'wicked'

Wicd is another utility that helps you manage connections to wired and wireless networks. It has no Gnome dependencies (although it does require GTK) and it should work on any Linux distribution (distro). It can be obtained from their Website or through your distro's repository. For specific installation instructions on a variety of distros, see their downloads page.

Once installed, clicking on its tray icon opens up the Wicd Manager, where all the action happens. As Figure 4 shows, you see an entry for the wired connection and each Wi-Fi network with its signal strength (percentage or dBm), encryption status, and physical (MAC) address.

Clicking an entry's arrow shows the details area, as you can see for the dlink network in Figure 4. For wireless networks you see another piece of information, the channel, plus buttons to configure custom scripts for the network and to set advanced settings, such as static IP and DNS addresses and encryption keys. Figure 5 shows all these areas: the Wicd Manager with a network's details plus the script and advanced setting windows. The settings you input into these windows are saved, so even if you go out of the network's range, the settings will return the next time it's detected-sort of a disappearing profile scheme. The details area of the wired connection is similar, however also contains a field where you can create and pick different profiles for the wired adapter, each configurable with static IP and DNS addresses.

Now for the application's toolbar. The Network menu provides the shortcuts to connect to hidden wireless networks and to create a ad-hoc network. Obviously, the Disconnect button disconnects you from the network and the Refresh button re-scans the airwaves for a updated list of Wi-Fi signals. The Preferences button takes you to where you can change advanced settings. Besides applying global DNS settings and switching to displaying signals in dBm, you probably can steer clear of these settings.

Though Wicd provides advanced features, such as profile-based IP settings, signal strength, and channel information, it lacks a simple window displaying the common connection details, such as the IP settings and MAC addresses. Nevertheless, you can use other methods to get the run down of connection details, such as by running the ifconfig -a or iwconfig command.

For the rest of the story, click here. 

Article courtesy of LinuxPlanet.

Originally published on .

Comment and Contribute
(Maximum characters: 1200). You have
characters left.