Review: Sputnik 720 Wi-Fi Hotspot Gateway
August 27, 2008
This pricey, high-performance hotspot gateway is customizable and easy to deploy.
Price: $279 $329 (hardware only, dependant upon radio configuration; required service/server imposes additional costs)
Pros: High performance; various authentication and billing methods; easy install
Cons: Pricy for entire solution; lacking Web content filter; no private LAN port
The word Sputnik naturally triggers thoughts of satellites and the start of the Space Race. If you arent familiar with Sputnik-1, the first artificial satellite to be put into space (by the Russians on October 4, 1957), you may have heard about the Sputnik program during its 40th anniversary in 1997. (We were lucky enough to catch the signals from the commemorative Sputnik 40 satellite using Amateur Radio gear.) Sputnik no longer orbits the earth. However, inspired by its groundbreaking impact on human communication, a San Francisco-based company that envisions a world filled with unlicensed, broadband wireless networking has taken it as its namesake.
Sputniks main offering, called SputnikNet, is a Wi-Fi hotspot management platform, which can be run on-site or hosted by Sputnik. Using supported gateways or wireless routers, SputnikNet centralizes the management and monitoring of multiple Wi-Fi hotspot locations. SputnikNet is even beneficial for owners of single hotspot locations, as it lets them better set up how access is given. For example, SputnikNet allows hotspot owners to charge end-users credit cards, offer guest access, or require end-users to view Terms of Service before using the connection.
Hotspot administrators have a variety of ways they can obtain a Sputnik gateway. They can upgrade supported third-party routers into Sputnik-powered gateways; they can purchase pre-upgraded routers available through Sputnik; or they can purchase the branded Sputnik 720 gateway. The Sputnik 720 is available as a wired-only gateway (switches and access points are used to create the wireless infrastructure) or as a gateway that has an integrated single or dual-band wireless access point (AP). We reviewed a Sputnik 720 loaded with a single 802.11g AP.
The Sputnik 720s set of features, at first glance, doesnt differ all that much from what a hotspot administrator can obtain from upgrading their own lower-priced routers, such as the Linksys WRT54GL ($60), to a Sputnik-powered gateway. However, after taking a closer look, the 720 handles larger and busier public networks better than its less expensive cousins. With its faster processor (266 MHz) and generous portion of memory (32 MB), the Sputnik 720 is designed to handle 100 or more concurrent authenticated usersas opposed to the estimated 30 users that the other routers can handle.
All Sputnik-powered routers run the open source DD-WRT firmware replacement, or a variant of it. DD-WRT is very popular among wireless administrators and has a solid reputation for being excellent firmware. In our experienceeven running on less powerful routers--it is reliable. Another plus about running the DD-WRT firmware is that hotspot administrators can take advantage of its enterprise-level features to customize the Sputnik gateway and their overall hotspot solution.
The Sputnik 720 sets itself apart from other routers by shipping with a 5 dBi gain antenna to increase the coverage area. Most of the other supported routers only have factory or rubber duck antennas that dont offer much gain. The router also supports Power over Ethernet (PoE), so hotspot administrators dont have to run both power and Ethernet cables to the gateway, which simplifies and reduces the cost of deployment.
Unfortunately, the Sputnik 720 gateway lacks a separate LAN port for a private network, such as the one seen on the D-Link Hotspot Gateway. It is possible to run the Sputnik 720 and a private network on a single Internet connection by using network polices and filtering, but having an additional port assigned to a different VLAN is preferable.
During our review of the Sputnik 720, we didnt experience any noticeable performance issues. The gateway performed great with the few end-users that were testing it out over several days. We didnt have any problems, such as the ones seen in the Wi-Fi Planet review of an earlier Sputnik router (2004 ).
The SputnikNet service
The SputnikNet service provides all the basic hotspot features and functionality one would expect, such as a customizable captive portal, payment options, and bandwidth limiting. We found it easy to remotely manage Sputnik gateways. Clicking on a gateway in the Control Panel lets the hotspot administrator change the SSID, channel, and power settings. Additionally, QoS settings can be defined to limit the amount of bandwidth hotspot end-users can use.
We were hoping that Sputnik would go above-and-beyond similar hotspot solutions with its content filtering features. However, we found SputnikNets filtering options require the hotspot administrator to manually input the addresses he or she wishes to block, which isnt a feasible method for blocking all inappropriate sites. A good content filter that would automatically block the hotspot end-users from visiting inappropriate sites would be a nice touch. We recommend the use of OpenDNS for third-party content filtering, which can be set up with Sputnik gateways.
Installation and configuration
For people moderately experienced with setting up wireless networks, the installation and configuration of the Sputnik 720 is straightforward. The basic steps include plugging the gateway into an electrical outlet, hooking up the Internet cable, connecting to the gateway, and entering the Sputnik ID into the Web page that comes up andvoila!its done. The gateway is then registered and the network administrator can configure and manage it through the online Sputnik Control Center.
Thanks to a few topics that are lacking in the documentation, we cant recommend the Sputnik 720 for Wi-Fi newbies. One item lacking from Sputniks extensive laundry list of installation documentation is a list of clear steps explaining how to run additional APs (or wireless routers) from the Sputnik 720 to increase coverage. Additionally, the documentation doesnt explain how to configure the WAN port for non-DHCP connections, such as DSL or static Internet connections.
Captive portal customization
We found the customization of the captive portal to be clear using the online documentation. Our dash of HTML knowledge and basic Web page design experience, however, really came in handy when branding the captive portal. For hotspot administrators without HTML experience, it would be very helpful if Sputnik included a simple template-maker. Then instead of having to customize the portal by editing the actual HTML and CSS code, hotspot administrators could choose to input their company info into a simple form that spits out a customized captive portal.
When shopping for your solution, keep in mind, though, that while the Sputnik 720 alone is priced under most traditional hotspot gateways, it also requires the fee-based SputnikNet service for full customization abilities. A Sputnik Agent Pro Subscription requires a one-time $49.95 set-up fee plus a whooping $499.50 annual fee per gateway (for the main gateway/router at each location).
Traditional hotspot gateways, though lacking the remote management features Sputnik provides, generally run $500 to $800 with no service fees. For those considering the Sputnik solution, the final decision comes down to whether or not having centralized monitoring and management of hotspot locations is worth the cost.
In a nutshell
We found that the Sputnik 720 is a high-performance hotspot gateway that is customizable and easy to deploy. Although we found a few ways that Sputnik could improve its product, the Sputnik 720 and the SputnikNet service provide a great hotspot solution for medium to large-sized establishments.
- For more by Eric Geier, read "WPA-Enterprise for Small Businesses (Part I)," "Intro to Wi-Fi Networking Using Windows Vista," and "How to: Add a Mac to your Windows Network (Part I)."
- For more access point and hotspot gateway reviews, read "Review: Apple AirPort Extreme," "Review: Ruckus Wireless ZoneFlex 7942 Access Point," and "Link Technologies' PoweRouter," or visit our Access Points Reviews page.
- For more on Sputnik, read "Sputnik Wi-Fi Hotzone Kit," "Sputnik's Temporary WLANs," or "Coastal Companies Launch Wi-Fi Access Businesses."