Review: Windows Live FolderShare 2008 Beta

By Joseph Moran

June 24, 2008

Microsoft's Windows Live FolderShare 2008 software makes sharing (and synchronizing) files across multiple systems an exercise in simplicity even when working remotely.

When you've got files you need to access on several computers but no central location — like a server or NAS device — on which to store them, it's not uncommon to turn to Windows built-in file sharing feature. But this approach is far from ideal since it often requires fiddling with firewalls to get it to work properly and it's limited to use on a LAN (at least without extra measures like a VPN).

Microsoft's Windows Live FolderShare 2008 software makes sharing (and synchronizing) files across multiple systems an exercise in simplicity no matter where they are. And for good measure, it also lets you to share files with others outside your network, and it can give you remote access to your own files while on the road.

Setup and sharing

FolderShare recently got an overhaul, though it is still a Beta offering. The utility is free and available at www.foldershare.com in versions for both Windows Vista/XP and Mac OS X 10.3.8 or later (though the Mac version hasn't been updated as recently as the Windows one). We used FolderShare on a pair of systems running Vista Home Premium.

Windows Live Microsoft FolderShare 2008 Beta
After you install the software on your computers, you create and manage shared folders via the FolderShare web site. (Click for larger image)

As you run the FolderShare installation wizard you're prompted to create a user account and are given the Windows Live moniker, you'd think that you could log in with an existing Windows Live ID. That's not the case, however, because Microsoft purchased FolderShare from another company several years ago and has apparently not yet fully integrated it into the Live infrastructure (though support for Live IDs is planned).

Once the software is up and running on each of your computers, you use the FolderShare Web site rather than the utility itself to select folders to be shared. These folders are called Personal Libraries, and setting them up is easy via the browser-based interface (which incidentally works just fine with Firefox).

After choosing an available system, you can browse its entire folder structure with the special folders — Documents, Favorites, Music, Pictures, and Desktop — at the top of the list. (You can't access mapped network drives, however.) When you select a folder and a destination system, the SSL-encrypted data transfer immediately begins, and how long this takes depends on whether the systems involved are connected via LAN or a significantly slower Internet connection. In the latter case, initial transfers/synchs can take some time, especially with large folders.

FolderShare does impose a few limitations worth mentioning. You can have a maximum of 10 Personal Libraries with 10,000 files in each, and individual file sizes are limited to 2GB, though most people probably won't bump up against these limits. Also, you can't use FolderShare to share individual files, and when selecting folders the files they contain aren't shown, which eliminates a point of reference if you're not exactly sure where the information you're looking for is stored. (You can get around this using the Remote Access feature we discuss later, but it's a little inconvenient.) Another complaint is that the folder names displayed on the FolderShare site are truncated down to about nine characters, so you may have to double-click some of them to view the full labels.

Synchronization

Once a Personal Library is established between computers, any files that are added or changed are synchronized across all systems as long as they're connected to the Internet. If changes occur while a system is offline, the synchronization takes place whenever the connection is re-established.

FolderShare's capability to handle synchronization conflicts is limited. If the same file changes on different systems while one of them is offline, at synch time FolderShare will simply retain both versions, renaming one of them to reference the user and system of origin. That's infinitely preferable to say, keeping only the one with the most recent time/date stamp, but it does leave it up to you to manually consolidate the two files or figure out which one to keep.

Spread the wealth (of information)

FolderShare doesn't limit you to just sharing folders among your own computers — you can also use it to share folders with others, like friends, family and colleagues. These Shared Libraries can either be created from existing Personal Libraries or set up separately.

To grant someone access to a Shared Library, you specify that person's e-mail address so he or she can be sent an e-mail invitation to download FolderShare and set up an account. You can substitute your own text for the two-sentence boilerplate of the message body, but the subject line's fixed reference to your e-mail address can't be modified. We wish it could, though, to minimize the chance that those using addresses unfamiliar to their recipients find their invitations inadvertently relegated to the spam bin.

When adding a user to a Shared Library you must also choose one of four permission levels — Reader, Contributor, Editor and Senior Editor. Readers can view files within a Shared Library but not add or modify them. Contributors gain the capability to add files, but still can't modify or delete any. Editors get unrestricted file access, while Senor Editors get the added ability to change the library permissions of other users.

Remote access

Even if you haven't designated a folder as a Personal or Shared Library, you can still access its contents provided the system on which it resides is online and running FolderShare. When logged into the FolderShare site, a Remote access feature lets you browse the folder structure of any connected system much as you do when creating a Library, except that all the files are displayed and are downloadable. Accessing files this way simply creates a duplicate copy and doesn't involve any synchronization, but it can be a handy way to get at distant files in a pinch.

While FolderShare does have some limitations and usability quirks, they don't undermine the essential promise of the software. If you're looking for a quick and easy way to share files on your own network or with others, Windows Live FolderShare 2008 is up to the task.

Windows Live Microsoft FolderShare 2008 Beta
Price: Free
Pros: extremely simple installation and setup; lets you share/sync folders between your own computers, or with others
Cons: no automatic synch conflict resolution; doesn't use Windows Live ID; limited to 10 shared folders ( 10,000 files per) and 2GB maximum file size

Story adapted from PracticallyNetworked.


Comment and Contribute
(Maximum characters: 1200). You have
characters left.