Linksys Wireless-G Media Storage Link Router
June 02, 2006
Plug any USB hard drive into this router and use it as a network-attached storage drive. It's a neat idea, but it does have its limits.
Network attached storage (NAS)
The WRTSL54GS is an all-in-one solution for Internet sharing and 802.11g WLAN and wired LAN switching. It includes four 10/100 Mbps Ethernet ports for plugging in wired devices and a port for plugging in a high-speed modem. The product supports both WPA2 (Wi-Fi Protected Access-2) security and Wi-Fi Multimedia (WMM), aka Wireless Multimedia Extensions (WME), a quality of service (QoS) protocol for prioritizing multimedia traffic on a Wi-Fi network.
The Media Storage Link has the compact form factor of some other recent Linksys router products. It measures 5.51 x 5.51 x 1.06 inches and weighs only 0.6 lbs. It can be mounted on the wall with screws or placed flat on a table or shelf. It also has an integrated stand that slides out, allowing you to stand it on edge.
The product performed well enough on basic file sharing functions, but set-up was a little bumpy and I encountered problems using it with one particular backup program that are still unresolved at the time of writing. It's difficult to be certain, however, whether these issues are entirely or at all attributable to the Linksys product.
If you're looking for a NAS solution and you have a suitable USB drive, the Media Storage Link Router will save you some money. In fact, it can save you money even if you don't already have the USB drive.
Consider this: The 300GB Maxtor OneTouch III product, a popular high-speed USB drive, sells for about $200. Total investment for a 300GB NAS solution with the Linksys router: $300. That compares to $400 for the NAS appliance alone if you buy Buffalo Technology's 300GB LinkStation product that we reviewed here recently.
The Linksys product includes other features that will sweeten the pot for some users. It uses the company's SpeedBooster wireless enhancement technology, which Linksys claims can increase network speeds up to 35 percent if you use the router with SpeedBooster-enabled Linksys network adapters. It will also supposedly give some improvement even when used with other vendors' products, but I saw no evidence of this in my testing.
The Media Storage Link also uses Linksys's One Touch Setup, which automates wireless setup of network devices with One Touch-enabled Linksys adapters.
Home users may find the media server feature useful some day. Many already use wireless media players that plug into a home entertainment system and stream music and video from the hard drive of a PC running proprietary media server software. The problem is the PC has to be turned on to play the media.
With the Media Storage Link, you can store music on the NAS drive. The media server software on the router will discover the music and serve it to a media player so long as the media player is compliant with UPnP (Universal Plug n Play) standards. The trouble is, as far as I can discover, there aren't any media players that offer this level of UPnP compliance. None of the three wireless media players I have on hand would work.
The case for NAS is clear. If you put files to be shared on a hard drive attached to one computer on the network, that computer must be turned on for other users to have access to the files, or be able to back up to the drive. Performance on the computer to which the drive is attached may also degrade when other users are accessing files or backing up.
More important, by putting vital company files on a NAS drive and having users back up to NAS, companies can better manage data security and integrity. Vital files and backups are no longer on storage media controlled by individual users who may not be as careful about data security as they should be. Centrally storing data makes it easier to ensure unauthorized people don't get access and version conflicts are avoided.
Like other NAS solutions, the Linksys product lets you set up "shares" volumes and folders on the NAS disk where shared files are stored, or to which users can back up. An administrator can set up groups of users and give them password protected access to certain shares and revoke access privileges as required. Users can use Windows to map shares so they show up as local drives in Windows Explorer, making it easy to access files and, theoretically, back up to the NAS.
Setting up the groups and shares, using the Media Storage Link's management utility, which you access in a browser window, is relatively simple. The documentation does, however, assume that you understand the basic concepts, which some small business users may not. And some of the dialogs are less than intuitive.
Initial set-up of the Linksys product did not go particularly smoothly. My test network includes a desktop PC and a Vonage voice over Internet (VoIP) adapter, both plugged directly into the router, plus two wirelessly connected computers, two wireless media players and a wireless network bridge. I plugged a 250GB Western Digital USB drive into the Media Storage Link's USB port.
I frequently swap out one router for another when reviewing products. In most cases, re-connecting the wireless devices is simple or completely automatic. One of the wireless media products, a Creative Labs SoundBlaster Wireless Music player, does almost always cause problems. It was particularly difficult to get it stabilized and working with the Linksys product. The Vonage adapter needed to be reconfigured before it would work, for the first time in three router swaps. The wireless bridge, a Linksys product, required a hard reset before it would work.
I was hampered in some of the troubleshooting by the fact that the management utility did not report the presence of some devices even after they were attached and working.
None of these problems was serious, other than as annoyances, and all were eventually resolved. In another network, with other devices, they may not even arise. I'm also not suggesting that the Linksys router is entirely to blame in all or even any of these cases. Networks can be complex beasts. Sometimes supposedly compatible network devices simply don't like each other.
In most testing with simple file sharing copying or moving files from local hard drives to the NAS drive the Media Storage Link worked fine. However, I did encounter some problems related to communicating with network shares that I have not experienced when transferring files to and from other network devices, and have not been able to resolve.
In a couple of cases, when transferring multiple files to the NAS drive using Windows Explorer, the transfer aborted after partially completing and Windows issued an error message suggesting this was because it had lost connection with the network drive. According to my research, the problem and error message can have a number of causes. Most appear to be unrelated to network hardware but, as noted, I have never encountered this problem when transferring files between other network devices.
I was also unable to use the Media Storage Link with an automated backup program, Retrospect Express 6.5 from EMC Insignia another problem that remains unresolved. When attempting to execute scheduled backup scripts, the program reported that it could not write to the NAS drive and issued an error message suggesting there was a problem with permissions. Again, it's not clear this occurs because of a flaw in the Linksys product. But it does occur.
Bottom line: The Media Storage Link is a neat idea that can save money on network attached storage. But make sure your dealer will take the product back, no questions asked, if you run into the kinds of problems described here.
Review courtesy of PracticallyNetworked.